After over a year of taunting us with the insanely priced TiVo HD the price has finally dropped to $300, which is well within an average tech geek's budget. I've been avoiding getting Comcast's HD DVR because I knew TiVo would find a way to get the price down and I've heard nothing but bad things about the Comcast HD DVR.
So after working with the my new TiVo for a couple of weeks, here's my assessment:
The Good
CableCARD support, good. Dual CableCARD support, AWESOME. TiVo managed to keep the dual tuner in the lower priced HD unit. In a way, this replaces two of my old TiVos. I already had a CableCARD in my TV, so I moved it to the TiVo with no issues. I had to get a Comcast technical out to my house to install the second card (I have no idea why), so it's nice they put the ports on the front of the device.
This may sound like a negative, but I'll explain. This cheaper TiVo has less storage space, in the realm of 20 hours of HD content, 180 hours of SD content. However, TiVo conveniently added an eSATA port to the back. This means I can easily add on more storage if the 20 hours is not enough for me. While the TiVo doc labels the port for "future use", it turns out it can be easily activated with current systems. Read more.
The CableCARD support really sums it all up. Everything else is pretty much the same (see below for a bad difference). I can now tune all my digital channels without a separate cable box and I finally get to watch my favorite shows the way they were meant to be seen when I am unavailable to watch them when they air.
The Bad
There is a short coming to the dual tuner. When I schedule shows to start early and run late (usually a 1 or 2 minute buffer) the TiVo will bounce between the tuners if it is recording back to back shows. This is desired if the shows are on separate channels, however not if both shows are on the same channel. It ends up interrupting me if I'm watching something else at the time. My only option is not to record the showing. I would like to also have an option to force it to record and clip on the other tuner.
My understanding is there's a legal debate going on with the CableCARD people. As a result, video transfer capability has been disabled on all Series 3 units. I can still access most of my Galleon features, but I cannot transfer shows between my TiVos. I can understand CableCARD's desire to protect content, but I would like to at least be able to transfer shows from my other two legacy TiVos to the new one. Keep outgoing transfers disabled but give me incoming transfers!
UPDATE: 11/7/2007
This option has finally been enabled! I can now move my recordings (standard def at least) between TiVos. Also, for $25 I can upgrade my TiVo Desktop to a version that will transcode the videos for use on portable devices. I haven't decided if I need this upgrade yet.
The Ugly
Well, none really. Like I said, this device is pretty much the same as my Series 2 boxes with dual-tuner and HD support added on. Performance-wise, it is no different. I suspect video transfers will not be disabled forever, so I'll patiently wait.